la fagIAnata
Menu Close

Story · 1904

The 1904 Tour disqualified its top four, and the win went to Cornet, nineteen when he reached Paris

Fans stopping the bunch, nails on the road, lifts in trains and cars: four months after the finish the French cycling union removed the top four and every stage winner, and the second Tour de France went to the man in fifth, Henri Cornet.

· 4 MIN READ ·
Black and white photo: in the centre a young rider in a white cap and white sweater holds his bicycle, surrounded by a crowd of men in hats and caps, next to an early motor car.
Henri Cornet, winner of the 1904 Tour de France, with his soigneurs at the start of the 1905 Tour in Noisy-le-Grand, 9 July 1905. Photo: Agence Rol, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Henri Cornet won the 1904 Tour de France in December, four months after the finish, by which time he had already turned twenty. In Paris, at the end of July, he had finished fifth. Ahead of him were Maurice Garin, who had won the first Tour the year before, Lucien Pothier, César Garin and Hippolyte Aucouturier. The French cycling union, the Union Vélocipédique de France, disqualified all four.

In that classification Cornet was 2h59′01 down. His time, 96h05′55″, did not change: the times ahead of his did. In July Garin had beaten Pothier by 3′28″ or 6′28″, depending on the source; in December Cornet found himself first, 2h16′14″ ahead of Jean-Baptiste Dortignacq.

Fans on the Col de la République

The second Tour left Montgeron on 2 July with 88 riders, on the same route as in 1903: six stages. On the very first, towards Lyon, Garin and Pothier were attacked by four masked men in a car. On the second, on the Col de la République near Saint-Étienne, between one and two hundred fans tried to stop the bunch so that Alfred Faure, a local rider, could get away. Garin was hit; the Italian Giovanni Gerbi was beaten, knocked unconscious and abandoned with broken fingers. The crowd only dispersed after pistol shots were fired.

At Nîmes, on the third stage, stones were thrown after Ferdinand Payan was disqualified. On several stages someone scattered nails and glass on the road. On the last stage Cornet rode between 35 and 40 km with one or two flat tyres, because outside help was forbidden. Some riders were thrown out during the race, among other things for taking lifts in cars or trains.

The verdict

The union ruled on 30 November, and the classification was ratified on 2 December. Along with the top four, every stage winner was disqualified: Garin had won the first stage, Pothier the fourth, Aucouturier the other four. 6 of 602 stages changed winner. How many riders were punished in all is unclear: sources give anything from eight to twenty-nine. Garin was suspended for two years, Pothier banned for life, a sentence later reduced. Cornet too received a warning. The precise reasons were never made public, and the papers of the inquiry were lost in 1940.

StageRoutekmWinner in JulyWinner in December
1Montgeron-Lyon467Maurice GarinMichel Frédérick
2Lyon-Marseille374Hippolyte AucouturierAlfred Faure
3Marseille-Toulouse423-424Hippolyte AucouturierHenri Cornet
4Toulouse-Bordeaux268Lucien PothierFrançois Beaugendre
5Bordeaux-Nantes425Hippolyte AucouturierJean-Baptiste Dortignacq
6Nantes-Paris461-471Hippolyte AucouturierJean-Baptiste Dortignacq
The six stages of the 1904 Tour, before and after the verdict.

Of the 88 starters, 27 had reached Paris; the final classification kept 15 of 8803. Henri Desgrange, the organiser, wrote in his newspaper, L’Auto, that he feared this had been the last Tour. Then he changed his mind, and changed the rules: in 1905 the classification was decided on points, to discourage cheating.

Nineteen years and eleven months

Cornet was born on 4 August 1884 in Desvres. He was registered as Henri David, his mother’s surname; later he took his stepfather’s, Jardry. When he reached Paris he was 19 years and 11 months old, and he is still the youngest winner of the Tour. He rode seven more Tours, never again as a leading man.

In 2026 Tadej Pogačar won the Tour by 6′26″ over Remco Evenepoel, and 158 of the 184 starters finished. In 1904 Garin’s victory lasted four months.

Sources

Written with the help of Mnemosyne.

Share WhatsApp Telegram Email

Found a mistake? Let us know: we’ll fix it and note the correction at the end of the article, with the date.