Polarised training is a way of distributing the week’s fatigue: lots of easy work, almost nothing in the middle and a slice of hard work. In reviews of elite endurance athletes the proportion that keeps coming up is this: about 80% of the time at low intensity, below 2 mmol/L of blood lactate, and about 20% at high intensity. Anyone who has heard of “zone 2” and of “doing intervals” already holds the two ends of the question, even without knowing where the thresholds that separate them lie. The polarised model targets the space between the two, and empties it. In the studies it works, but the alternatives work too: the advantage it is credited with is slight and shows up only in certain contexts. Professionals, meanwhile, train in a different way, with far more time in the middle than the label would suggest. To measure all these differences the yardstick is an imaginary rider who trains 15 hours a week, that is 900 minutes.
In brief
- In a meta-analysis of 17 studies and 437 participants, polarised training has a small advantage in VO2peak (0.24) and none in time-trial performance.
- Professionals train in a pyramid: at the Tour de France, over 22 days of racing, 70-23-7 across the three zones.
- In race weeks the high intensity of three riders who finished in the top five at the Giro reaches about 9-12% of the time.
- The idea comes from the training of elite rowers and distance runners, not from that of cyclists.
- “Polarised” does not mean the same thing in every study: that is why there is an index to measure it.
The three zones: lactate thresholds and ventilatory thresholds
In physiology, intensity is measured neither in kilometres per hour nor in absolute watts: it is measured by how heavily an effort weighs on the body, and there are two reference points, the thresholds. They can be read in blood lactate or in breathing, with the ventilatory thresholds. In both cases they divide effort into three parts, and these are the three zones that studies on polarisation talk about.
Zone 1 lies below the first threshold, with lactate of about 2 mmol/L or less. Zone 2 lies between the first and the second threshold and is the intensity known as “threshold”, with lactate around 4 mmol/L or with breathing at the second ventilatory threshold. Zone 3 starts above 4 mmol/L and runs up to efforts close to VO2max.
Anyone using a power meter should watch out for a name. Zone 2 in this model is the middle one, between the two thresholds, and is not the Z2 on your bike computer, the one from the power zones Z1 to Z7.
The 15-hour-a-week rider in three versions
Our rider has 900 minutes a week and three ways of dividing them among the zones. The first is the pyramidal distribution, the traditional one: the share falls from zone 1 to zone 3, that is, plenty of endurance, a portion of threshold work and a pinch of hard work. Drawn by zones it has exactly the shape of a pyramid, with the wide base at the bottom.
| Distribution | Zone 1-2-3 (%) | Zone 1 (minutes) | Zone 2 (minutes) | Zone 3 (minutes) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyramidal | 80-15-5 | 720 | 135 | 45 |
| Polarised | 80-0-20 | 720 | 0 | 180 |
| Threshold | 57-43-0 | about 510 | about 390 | 0 |
The second way is polarised. The easy part stays identical, twelve hours in zone 1, but zone 2 disappears and the time above the second threshold rises to three hours. Set side by side, the two weeks have the same easy volume: in both there are 180 minutes above the first threshold, and the only change is where they are taken. The pyramid splits them between threshold and hard work, the polarised week puts them all at the top.
The threshold distribution turns things around
The third way is the threshold distribution: less than nine easy hours, six and a half hours in zone 2 and nothing above. None of the three is a programme to follow. They are three ways of reading the same week, and they are the shapes that studies pit against each other when asking which works best.
Where the idea comes from and how the polarisation index is calculated
The calculation
- The polarisation index is calculated from the shares of the three zones: log10(zone 1 / zone 2 × zone 3 × 100).
- It is valid only if zone 1 is greater than zone 3 and zone 3 is greater than zone 2.
- The rider’s polarised week, 80-0-20, scores 3.18: it is polarised.
- A 74-11-15 week scores 2.00: almost polarised, but not polarised.
Above 2.00 the distribution is polarised; at 2.00 or below it is not.
The idea comes from elite rowers and distance runners
The polarised distribution was not born in a cycling lab. It was proposed by looking at how elite rowers and distance runners actually trained: a lot of time in zone 1, a lot of work in zone 3 and little in zone 2.
The same reviews of elite athletes yield a second finding, which shows how little of the hard part is needed: two high-intensity sessions a week are enough to induce adaptations. Pushing high intensity on already highly trained athletes, by contrast, has given ambiguous results.
An index tells you when a week is polarised
An index was created to establish when a week can be called polarised. It is calculated from the shares of the three zones, and a distribution is polarised if the index exceeds 2.00, if zone 1 is bigger than zone 3 and if zone 3 is bigger than zone 2. The rider’s polarised week clears the threshold by a wide margin. The pyramidal one does not even get to the calculation, because its zone 2 is bigger than its zone 3. A 74-11-15 week, which by eye would look polarised, stops exactly on the border.
The number matters because in the literature the word does not always mean the same thing. From one study to another “polarised” indicates different distributions, and sometimes even distributions that by the index would count as pyramidal. Two pieces of research claiming to compare the same thing may therefore have tested very different weeks.
Professionals train in a pyramid, not in a polarised way
To find out what top cyclists really do, thirteen professionals were followed for seven months with heart rate, from active rest through to the Tour de France. In every phase most of the time is spent in zone 1, as polarised training also requires, but the shape is pyramidal: zone 2 is always bigger than zone 3, and the index does not even start to count.
The professionals’ zone 2 is therefore not an error to be corrected: it is the shape of their work, and the Tour shows it well. Time trials and high-mountain stages shift the weight upwards, but what rises most is zone 2, which reaches 23%, while zone 3 stays at 7%. Even in the hardest race of the year the distribution remains a pyramid.
The Giro’s three top 5 finishers: more polarised in racing than in training
The Giro’s three top 5 finishers train in a pyramid
The picture closest to our rider comes from three cyclists who finished in the top five at the Giro d’Italia between 2015 and 2018, analysed over the 22 weeks before the race. They trained on average between 14.7 and 19.7 hours a week: at 15 hours, the imaginary rider sits in the same range as the lightest of the three. All three spent the great majority of their time in zone 1, and their polarisation index stayed between 1.47 and 1.65: below the 2.00 border, inside the pyramid.
Racing changes the picture. In race weeks the index rises to between 1.76 and 1.89 and the share of high intensity reaches about a tenth of racing time. Hard work in a race comes more easily than in training, because rivals ease the effort. None of the three did gym work, and their programme followed above all the racing calendar.
Zones change from study to study
Here the zones are calculated on FTP, with the border between zone 1 and zone 2 at 85% of FTP, whereas the thirteen professionals were measured by heart rate.
Zones change from study to study, and the numbers from different pieces of research never overlap perfectly. The sense is the same, though: in training the professionals stay in the pyramid, and in racing the index rises, with high intensity at about 9-12% of the time, but stays below the 2.00 threshold.
The studies compared: where polarised wins and where it does not
The experiments that have pitted our rider’s distributions against each other do not all reach the same answer.
| Who | Duration | Distributions compared (zone 1-2-3) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 48 well-trained athletes from four sports | 9 weeks | polarised about 68-6-26; threshold 46-54-0; low intensity only 83-16-1 | Polarised better: VO2peak +11.7%, time to exhaustion +17.4%, peak power +5.1% |
| 12 well-trained cyclists | 6 weeks, crossover | polarised 80-0-20; threshold 57-43-0 | Polarised better: peak power +8% vs +3%, power at lactate threshold +9% vs +2%, high-intensity capacity +85% vs +37% |
| 20 Norwegian distance runners | 5 months | high intensity and threshold; high volumes at low intensity | The high-intensity and threshold group did better |
| 18 British rowers | 12 weeks | two different distributions | Similar improvements in VO2peak and in the 2000 m test |
| 18 cross-country mountain bike riders, 17.9 years on average | — | polarised; low intensity | No significant difference; race power +4.4% vs -2.2% |
Studies in favour of polarised training
The clearest result comes from a randomised study of 48 well-trained athletes: runners, cyclists, triathletes and distance runners, split for nine weeks between polarised, threshold and low intensity only. The polarised group improved more in VO2peak, in time to exhaustion and in peak power. The other two did not: neither threshold work nor easy volume alone brought further improvements.
The study closest to our rider is the crossover one on twelve well-trained cyclists, because it tested exactly two of his three weeks, the 80-0-20 and the 57-43-0. Polarised won, with fewer minutes a week: 381 versus 458. For the rider this means that the week full of zone 2 did not give more than the one with the hard hours at the top. These are, however, short studies, of six to nine weeks, on small groups.
Other studies do not side with polarised training
Other research points in a different direction. In twenty Norwegian distance runners followed for five months, the group working at high intensity and threshold improved more than the one with large easy volumes. In eighteen British rowers, twelve weeks with two different distributions produced similar improvements, both in VO2peak and in the 2000 m test.
The case closest to cycling is that of eighteen young cross-country mountain bikers: between polarised and low intensity there was no significant difference, with only a small trend in favour of polarised in race power. Sport, level and duration change the response, and to weigh all these results you have to look at them together.
The meta-analysis: a small advantage, not a revolution
On VO2peak the advantage is small and uncertain
The overall picture comes from a meta-analysis that pooled experiments lasting at least four weeks in which polarised training was compared with other distributions. On VO2peak, the maximum oxygen consumption measured in the test, polarised has a small advantage, and an uncertain one too: the confidence interval starts just above zero, so the real advantage could be almost nil. In highly trained athletes the advantage is clearer, with a difference of 0.46 and an interval running from 0.10 to 0.82.
On time trials and the second threshold the difference disappears
On the measures closest to racing the difference disappears. In the time-trial test, in time to exhaustion and in power or speed at the second threshold, polarised does no better than the other distributions.
The 2025 reviews: each model has its own scenario
The 2025 reviews on cyclic sports read the same data without looking for a winning model. Pyramidal, threshold and polarised each have their own scenario of use and bring progress when they fit the sport and the phase of preparation. The choice depends on goals and on variability between individuals, and combining several models across the phases of the season can produce adaptations that add up.
Polarised training works, as do the alternatives, with a slight advantage in certain cases, while professionals train in a pyramid and in racing, even with high intensity at about 9-12% of the time, stay below the 2.00 threshold.
Why professionals stay on low intensity
The 15-hour rider, whether he picks the pyramid or polarised, spends twelve hours in zone 1 and has a weekly volume in the same range as the three Giro riders, between 14.7 and 19.7 hours, close to that of the lightest, who trained in a pyramid. What he has in common with the professionals is therefore the base, not the shape.
Low intensity is a paradox
A 2025 review of low-intensity training in endurance athletes calls it a paradox. A single easy ride does not shake the body enough to deliver gains comparable to those of moderate or high intensity, and yet athletes devote most of their hours to it. The explanations put forward are several and do not exclude each other. One part is psychological, the need for easy days; another is the way low intensity lets you accumulate work little by little without accumulating stress.
Athletes and coaches do not think alike
On this, athletes and coaches have not always agreed. Athletes prefer low intensity, which holds up better in large volumes, while most coaches have pushed towards higher intensities, with lactate between 2.5 and 4 mmol/L, mainly for theoretical reasons. Yet more threshold work, beyond 20% and at the expense of the easy part, gives no further adaptations. Among pyramidal, threshold and polarised, science still has no clear winner: the phase of the season matters, the sport matters and so does who is pedalling.
Written with the help of Mnemosyne.
Sources
- Stöggl T.L., Sperlich B., “The training intensity distribution among well-trained and elite endurance athletes”, Frontiers in Physiology, 2015, PMID 26578968, doi:10.3389/fphys.2015.00295.
- Treff G., Winkert K., Sareban M., Steinacker J.M., Sperlich B., “The Polarization-Index: A Simple Calculation to Distinguish Polarized From Non-polarized Training Intensity Distributions”, Frontiers in Physiology, 2019, PMID 31249533, doi:10.3389/fphys.2019.00707.
- Gallo G., Mateo-March M., Gotti D., Faelli E., Ruggeri P., Codella R., Filipas L., “How do world class top 5 Giro d’Italia finishers train? A qualitative multiple case study”, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 2022, PMID 35686390, doi:10.1111/sms.14201.
- Silva Oliveira P., Boppre G., Fonseca H., “Comparison of Polarized Versus Other Types of Endurance Training Intensity Distribution on Athletes’ Endurance Performance: A Systematic Review with Meta-analysis”, Sports Medicine, 2024, PMID 38717713, doi:10.1007/s40279-024-02034-z.
- Sun Q., Yu Y., Cui J., Lin S., Wang X., Zhou T., “Recent advances in training intensity distribution theory for cyclic endurance sports: theoretical foundations, model comparisons, and periodization characteristics”, Frontiers in Physiology, 2025, PMID 41169886, doi:10.3389/fphys.2025.1657892.