la fagIAnata
Menu Close

Polarised Training Explained: What the Research Shows and How WorldTour Pros Really Train

Mostly easy, a little hard, nothing in between: how the 80/20 split works for an amateur on 10 hours a week, what studies find and where WorldTour pros stand.

· 10 MIN READ
The guide10minutes to readmin

Polarised training is a way of distributing intensity: lots of easy work, little hard work and almost nothing in between. In numbers, about 75% of the time below the first threshold, 15-20% at high intensity and little or nothing between the two. This is the “80/20” you hear about.

In brief

  • The studies compared number 17, with 437 subjects: polarised training gives a small advantage in peak VO2 (SMD 0.24) and none in the time trial.
  • The advantage appears in trials shorter than 12 weeks and cannot be separated from the athletes’ training level.
  • The word “polarised” does not have a single meaning: it changes with the threshold used, with the measure (watts or heart rate) and with the way of counting (sessions or time).
  • Over 10 weeks of preparation by a WorldTour team, 16 men and 16 women, none turned out to be polarised.
  • For professionals and over the long term there is no experimental evidence: the study on the WorldTour riders observes, it does not prove.

To see it up close, take an amateur who trains 10 hours a week and has a critical power, that is, their threshold, of 250 W. With them the least obvious point becomes clear: the same month of training can be called polarised, pyramidal or threshold, depending on where the watts fall and how you count.

Studies find a small, mixed advantage. And the professionals observed in a WorldTour preparation do not train this way.

Three zones, two thresholds and three ways of distributing time

The zones sit between two thresholds and the models fill them differently

The body has two thresholds. Zone 1 lies below the first ventilatory threshold (VT1, about 2 mmol/L of blood lactate). Zone 2 lies between VT1 and VT2, from about 2 to about 4 mmol/L. Zone 3 lies above VT2, beyond about 4 mmol/L.

Three models are built on these three zones. The pyramidal has more time in zone 1 than in zone 2 and more in zone 2 than in zone 3: a descending staircase. The threshold model puts most of the time between the two thresholds. The polarised model leaves the middle empty: about 75% below the first threshold, 15-20% at high intensity.

For the 250 W amateur the boundaries are counted in watts

Boundaries in watts are needed. Here we use those of a study on WorldTour professionals: zone 1 is below 70% of critical power, zone 3 above critical power. So zone 1 is below 175 W, zone 2 between 175 and 250 W, zone 3 above 250 W.

They hold for that study: with lactate or ventilatory thresholds the boundaries fall elsewhere. The seven-level scale is in the guide to power zones; the threshold in watts is in the guide to critical power and W′.

The label changes with the measure used

Distribution can be measured with power, heart rate, perceived effort or lactate, and each draws its own boundaries. Heart rate, moreover, responds slowly in short efforts, which is why cycling looks to the power meter. Figures from studies with different definitions cannot be compared as if they were equal. Even a threshold in watts changes with the test: see the guide toFTP.

To say whether a distribution is polarised, an index is used: above 2, it is. With heart rate, polarised distributions appear more often than with power: in the WorldTour study, 2 women and 3 men had more time in zone 3 than in zone 2. Almost none exceeded the polarisation threshold.

The same 10-hour month read in three ways

Back to the amateur: 10 hours a week, zone 1 below 175 W, zone 2 between 175 and 250 W, zone 3 above 250 W. If the week is made up of about 75% in zone 1, about 20% in zone 3 and half an hour or a little more in the middle, it is polarised. If zone 1 accounts for 70%, zone 2 for 20% and zone 3 for 10%, it is pyramidal. If more than half the hours fall between 175 and 250 W, it is threshold. These are three round examples of our own, not data from a study.

Then there is the way of counting. A week of ten rides, eight easy and two hard, is 80/20 if you count sessions. If you count hours it becomes pyramidal: even the hard rides include a warm-up and recovery, and zone 1 rises to 90%. The same happens with the groups observed in studies: in cross-country skiing, counting sessions gives about 75% in zone 1 and 15-20% in zone 3; counting time or distance, zone 1 exceeds 90%.

The label therefore depends on three things: where the watts fall, how you count and which threshold you use.

The sums

  1. Boundaries in watts, with critical power at 250 W: 70% of 250 W is 175 W. Zone 1 below 175 W, zone 2 from 175 to 250 W, zone 3 above 250 W.
  2. The 10 hours read three ways. Polarised: 7 h 30′ in zone 1, 30′ in zone 2, 2 h in zone 3 (75%, 5%, 20%). Pyramidal: 7 h, 2 h, 1 h (70%, 20%, 10%). Threshold: 2 h 30′, 5 h 30′, 2 h (25%, 55%, 20%).
  3. The same week counted two ways: 10 rides, 8 easy and 2 hard. By sessions it is 80/20. By time, if each hard ride of 1 h has 30′ easy, 20′ in zone 2 and 10′ in zone 3: 9 h in zone 1, 40′ in zone 2, 20′ in zone 3 (about 90%, 7%, 3%), that is, pyramidal.

Same 10 hours, different labels: it depends on where the watts fall and how you count.

Where the idea of polarised training comes from

It is talked about because of two pieces of work. In the first, 48 endurance athletes trained for 9 weeks: polarised training improved more peak VO2 (+12%), time to exhaustion (+17%) and peak power (+5%). Maximal VO2 is covered in the guide to VO2max in cycling. In the second, 12 cyclists over 6 weeks, polarised against threshold: lactate threshold rose by 9% against 3%, peak power by 8% against 3%.

The other push is an observation: elite endurance athletes spend much of their training in the low zone. It is a paradox, because at low intensity the acute stimulus on high-level athletes is modest. Seven hypotheses have been put forward to explain it, not all mutually exclusive: from the psychological need for easy days to benefits without accumulating stress.

The 2024 meta-analysis: a small, circumscribed advantage

On peak VO2 the effect is small and appears only in short trials

A meta-analysis pools the results of many studies and draws a single number from them. Here polarised training beats the other distributions on peak VO2, but with a small effect, and the confidence interval comes close to zero. “Small” in SMD means that the distance between the group means is slight, compared with how much athletes vary from one person to another.

The advantage appears only in interventions shorter than 12 weeks (SMD 0.40); from 12 weeks onwards it disappears (0.04). It also appears, and only, in highly trained athletes (0.46). The two factors cannot be separated: the highly trained athletes were mostly in the short studies.

On time trial and second threshold nothing changes

In the time trial there is no difference between polarised and the other distributions (SMD -0.01), nor at the second threshold, in speed or in power (0.04). Time to exhaustion favours polarised, but not significantly (0.30). No single comparison with threshold, pyramidal or high-intensity intervals reaches significance.

The limitations weigh heavily. The samples are small: the median is 22 people per study. Several studies do not report the percentage of time in the zones. Many randomised studies leave some concern about risk of bias, and an analysis by sex was not possible. Only four studies involve cyclists, on the road and on mountain bikes.

Three weeks on the mountain bike: an example with few athletes

One study took 18 cross-country mountain bike athletes, average age about 18, and split them at random into two groups. The first did three weeks of polarised training: about 86.6% of the time below the lactate threshold, 13.4% above, nothing in between; 8 intense sessions, about 25 hours. The second did three weeks of low intensity only: 14 sessions, about 40 hours. The load was similar.

No significant difference. Average race power rose by 4.4% with polarised and fell by 2.2% with low intensity. But with 18 participants the study could only see enormous effects: to have an 80% chance of detecting a difference, one of 1.66 was needed. A small effect, like those in the meta-analysis, could not emerge.

The athletes liked the polarised approach more: more varied, with fewer hours. Many athletes and coaches prefer it because it gives at least equivalent effects with less training time. The study does not allow us to say that either approach works better.

The WorldTour professionals observed are pyramidal

Ten weeks of preparation: none is polarised

The study followed the ten weeks before the first race of the year, with data from 2018, of 16 men and 16 women from the same WorldTour team: about 50 rides each. None turned out to be polarised: the indices were all below 2. The riders followed a pyramidal distribution, apart from one woman on threshold. These are the numbers for that period and that team, not for the whole season or for grand tour riders.

DistributionZone 1Zone 2Zone 3
Polarised (model)about 75%little or nothing15-20%
WorldTour male professionals70,4%25,4%4,2%
WorldTour female professionals59,7%32,8%7,4%
Percentage of time in each zone. For the professionals the zones are those of the study: zone 1 below 70% of critical power, zone 3 above critical power. The polarised model uses lactate thresholds: it should not be compared to the decimal.

Next to the amateur’s polarised month, which spends two hours in ten in zone 3, the difference is stark: it is about five times the share of the WorldTour men. The middle that polarised training empties is, for them, occupied by about a quarter of the time, for the women by about a third.

The watts are different too. Estimated critical power is 380 W for the men and 237 W for the women: the amateur’s 175 and 250 W are their own boundaries, not theirs. For the men zone 1 ends at around 266 W, 70% of 380; for the women, at around 166 W.

The men train 19.1 hours a week, the women 16.7, with the same load (TSS 847 against 848 a week). With fewer hours, the women spend more time at medium-high intensity.

It is an observation, not proof of what works

The study’s authors write that there is no experimental evidence on the optimal distribution in professionals. Most elite endurance athletes adopt a pyramidal distribution with a lot of low-intensity volume, but the study is observational: it records what they do and does not allow cause and effect to be established.

Other data on elite cyclists point the same way, with different thresholds and so without a comparison to the decimal: from 63% to 88% of the time below the first threshold and from about 2% to 9% above the second.

Volume matters too. Ten hours a week makes about 520 hours a year. Those who train about 350 hours a year tend towards a distribution similar to threshold; those who exceed 750 hours tend towards polarised or pyramidal. The 250 W amateur sits in between.

Where the research disagrees and what can be said

The readings diverge. A 2022 paper judges the evidence insufficient to support universal advantages of polarised training. Another, from 2020, found threshold more useful for preserving neuromuscular function and polarised more useful for VO2max. And pyramidal distribution is common in cycling and rowing.

A systematic review of 14 studies on VO2max and movement economy concludes that polarised training works in the short term, with about 15-20% high intensity and 75-80% low, but that the limited number of studies restricts how far it can be generalised. A narrative review, with no registered protocol, concludes that no model is absolutely superior.

So what can be said: over the short term there is a small advantage; over the long term and in professionals there is no experimental evidence.

The 250 W amateur now knows that their label depends on their own sums: on the boundary watts, the way of counting, the threshold chosen. What the studies say boils down to mostly easy, the rest depends. The scale of levels is in the guide to power zones.

Written with the help of Mnemosyne.

Sources

Share WhatsApp Telegram Email

Found a mistake? Let us know: we’ll fix it and note the correction at the end of the article, with the date.

Newsletter · every Sunday

Liked it? The rest of the week arrives on Sunday, in a single email.

We don’t share your email with anyone: Substack keeps it and sends the newsletter. Unsubscribe with one click. Privacy